Auto Insurance Β· Claims

Auto insurance subrogation: how your insurer recovers costs, and how you get your deductible back

Another driver hits you, and instead of waiting on their insurer, you file with your own collision coverage. Your repairs get done quickly, but you paid a deductible for a crash that wasn't your fault. Can you get that money back? Often, yes, through a process called subrogation. Here's how subrogation works, how your deductible fits in, and the one thing you shouldn't do while it's underway, based on guidance from the Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner.

Fact-checked against the Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner. Every source is listed at the end of this article.
Damaged red vehicle strapped to a flatbed tow truck
AUTO INSURANCE GUIDEYour deductibleWhat you may get back when your insurer recovers costs from the at-fault driver

In 30 seconds

  • Subrogation is when your insurer tries to recover what it paid on your claim from the person who caused the damage.
  • In Washington, your insurer must include your deductible in its subrogation demand to the at-fault party.
  • If you were partly at fault, you may get back only a percentage of your deductible.
  • Tell your insurer before you agree to any settlement with the at-fault driver or their insurer, so you don't risk its right to subrogation.
In this article

    Subrogation at a glance

    • What it is: your insurer recovers costs from the at-fault party
    • Your deductible: included in the demand (Washington rule)
    • Partly at fault: you may recover only part of your deductible
    • Before settling: tell your insurer first
    • Washington help line: 800-562-6900

    From the Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner, What is subrogation?

    What subrogation means

    The Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner explains it this way: your insurance company can try to recover the costs it paid from the person who caused your injury or property damage. This is known as subrogation.

    In practice, you get paid by your own insurer first, without waiting for the other driver's insurer to accept fault. Your insurer then goes after the at-fault driver, or more often their insurer, for the money. If it succeeds, it gets back what it paid, and you may get back your deductible.

    How your deductible fits in

    When you use your own collision coverage, you pay your deductible. In Washington, the insurance commissioner says your company must include your deductible in its subrogation demand to the at-fault party. If your insurer recovers the money, your share comes back to you.

    OutcomeWhat happens to your deductible
    The other driver is found fully at fault and the insurer recoversYou may get your full deductible back
    You're found partly at faultYou may recover only a percentage of your deductible
    Nothing is recoveredYour deductible usually isn't returned

    Based on the Washington OIC. Rules vary by state, so ask your insurer how it handles deductibles in subrogation.

    Ask about timing

    Subrogation can take weeks or months, especially if fault is disputed. Ask your insurer to keep you updated and to let you know when it recovers anything.

    Don't settle on your own

    This is the most important step for you. The Washington OIC says to tell your insurer before agreeing to any settlement with the at-fault party or their insurer. Notifying your insurer in advance ensures you don't risk your company's right to subrogation.

    If you sign a release with the other driver's insurer without telling your own, you could accidentally give up the right your insurer needs to recover its money, and with it, your chance to get your deductible back. The OIC adds that these obligations shouldn't interfere with you receiving your benefits and full payment.

    How it plays out

    Dana's rear-end crash

    Dana is stopped at a red light in Spokane when another driver rear-ends her. The other driver's insurer is slow to respond, so Dana files with her own collision coverage to get her car fixed.

    Her repairs cost $4,000. She pays her $500 deductible, and her insurer pays $3,500.

    Her insurer then pursues the other driver's insurer for the full $4,000, including Dana's deductible. A few months later, it recovers the money and sends Dana her $500.

    Along the way, the other driver's insurer offers Dana a small payment to sign a release. She calls her own insurer first, and they advise her on how it would affect their recovery.

    Illustrative example. Names and amounts are made up. Timelines vary.

    Subrogation and your rates

    Subrogation is about who pays for the damage. Whether a crash affects your premium depends on your insurer's rules and on who was at fault. If you're found not at fault, ask your insurer how the claim will be treated at renewal.

    What to do after a not-at-fault crash

    1. Get the other driver's information Collect their name, insurance company and policy number, and take photos.
    2. Decide how to file You can file with the other driver's insurer or with your own collision coverage.
    3. Keep your receipts Keep proof of your deductible and any other costs, such as a rental car.
    4. Don't sign a release without checking Tell your insurer before settling with the other side.
    5. Follow up Ask your insurer about the status of subrogation and your deductible.

    In Washington, you can call the insurance commissioner's consumer advocacy line at 800-562-6900, Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Other states' insurance departments have similar help lines if you have a problem with a claim.

    Your insurer or theirs: which claim to file

    After a crash that wasn't your fault, you usually have two choices. You can file a third-party claim directly with the other driver's insurer, or file a first-party claim with your own collision coverage and let subrogation sort it out later. Each route has tradeoffs:

    File with the other driver's insurerFile with your own insurer
    DeductibleUsually noneYou pay it up front, then may get it back through subrogation
    SpeedCan be slower if fault is disputedOften faster, since your insurer handles it
    Who negotiatesYou deal with the other insurerYour insurer deals with the other insurer
    Coverage neededNone of your ownCollision coverage on your policy

    General comparison. Your policy and your state's rules apply.

    If the other insurer is quick to accept fault, filing with them may save you the deductible. If they're slow or fault is unclear, using your own coverage gets your car fixed sooner, and subrogation may bring your deductible back.

    Keep your paperwork together

    Subrogation can take a while, so good records help you track it. Save the police report number if there is one, photos of both vehicles, the other driver's insurance details, repair estimates and your claim number. Ask your adjuster to tell you when the subrogation demand is sent and when money is recovered, so you know when to expect your deductible back.

    Frequently asked questions

    Who do I call if my insurer won't explain subrogation?

    Your state insurance department. In Washington, the Office of the Insurance Commissioner's consumer line is 800-562-6900.

    Do I need collision coverage to use subrogation?

    To file with your own insurer for vehicle damage, you generally need collision coverage. Your insurer can then pursue the at-fault driver's insurer through subrogation.

    What if the at-fault driver has no insurance?

    Your insurer may still try to recover from the driver, but it can be harder. Uninsured motorist property damage coverage, where available, may also help.

    What is subrogation in auto insurance?

    It's when your insurer pays your claim and then tries to recover the costs from the person who caused the damage, or their insurer.

    Will I get my deductible back through subrogation?

    Often, if your insurer recovers the money. In Washington, insurers must include your deductible in their subrogation demand. If you were partly at fault, you may get back only part of it.

    How long does subrogation take?

    It varies. It can take weeks or months, especially if fault is disputed. Ask your insurer for updates.

    Can I settle with the other driver's insurer myself?

    Tell your own insurer before agreeing to any settlement. Settling on your own could put your insurer's right to subrogation, and your deductible, at risk.

    Does subrogation affect my insurance rates?

    Subrogation is about who pays for the damage. Whether a claim affects your premium depends on your insurer's rules and on fault, so ask your insurer.

    Your next step

    See what you could pay

    Compare options available where you live, or call to talk it through with a licensed agent. Looking is free.

    ConnectingCrowd is an information site and is not affiliated with any government agency.

    Compare auto insurance options

    Sponsored

    See auto insurance options near you

    Rates and available coverages vary by state and insurer. Add your ZIP code to compare. It is free and you are not committing to anything.

    Find auto insurance that fits your loan or lease

    Sponsored
    Was this article helpful?

    Want a policy that handles claims well?

    Compare auto insurance options where you live.