Auto Insurance Β· Claims

Car seat replacement after an accident: when you need a new one, and who pays

After a crash, once everyone is safe, parents often look in the back seat and wonder: is my child's car seat still safe to use? It may look fine, but a crash can weaken a seat in ways you can't see. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has a simple test for deciding whether a seat can stay in service. Here's how to use it, and how to ask your auto insurance company about paying for a replacement.

Fact-checked against the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). Every source is listed at the end of this article.
Two vehicles damaged after a crash on a city street
AUTO INSURANCE GUIDE5 conditionsAll must be true for NHTSA to consider a crash minor

In 30 seconds

  • NHTSA recommends replacing car seats after a moderate or severe crash.
  • A crash counts as minor, and the seat may not need replacing, only if all five of NHTSA's conditions are true.
  • If even one condition isn't met, treat the crash as moderate or severe and replace the seat.
  • Whether your insurer pays for a new seat depends on your policy and claim, so ask when you file.
In this article

    NHTSA's minor crash test

    • The vehicle could be driven away from the crash site
    • The door nearest the car seat wasn't damaged
    • No one in the vehicle was injured
    • The air bags (if any) didn't deploy
    • There's no visible damage to the car seat

    All five must be true for a minor crash. Source: NHTSA, Car seat use after a crash.

    Why a crash can make a car seat unsafe

    A car seat is built to absorb a huge amount of force once. In a crash, the shell, harness and anchors can be stressed or cracked in ways that aren't visible from the outside. A seat that's been through a serious crash may not protect a child the same way in the next one. That's why NHTSA recommends that car seats be replaced following a moderate or severe crash.

    NHTSA's five-point minor crash test

    NHTSA says a crash is minor only if all five of these are true:

    1. The vehicle could be driven away The vehicle was able to be driven away from the crash site.
    2. The nearest door wasn't damaged The vehicle door nearest the car seat was not damaged.
    3. No one was injured None of the passengers in the vehicle had any injuries in the crash.
    4. The air bags didn't deploy If the vehicle has air bags, they did not deploy.
    5. The seat shows no damage There's no visible damage to the car seat.

    If you can check off all five, NHTSA considers it a minor crash, and the seat may not need to be replaced. If any one of them isn't true, treat it as a moderate or severe crash and replace the seat.

    Check the manual too

    Your car seat's manual may have its own guidance on crashes. Read it, and follow the stricter rule if they differ.

    Two examples

    SituationReplace the seat?
    Low-speed bump in a parking lot. Car driven home, no injuries, no air bags, door and seat fine.All five conditions met: NHTSA considers it minor
    Same bump, but the rear door next to the seat is dentedOne condition fails: replace the seat
    Highway crash where the air bags deployedReplace the seat
    Crash where a passenger in the front seat was hurtReplace the seat

    Based on NHTSA's criteria. When in doubt, replace the seat.

    Will auto insurance pay for a new car seat?

    NHTSA's guidance is about safety, not insurance, and there's no single rule that says every insurer must pay for a new car seat. Whether yours will depends on your policy, which coverage applies to the claim, and who was at fault.

    • βœ“ Ask when you file. Tell the claims adjuster a child's car seat was in the vehicle and ask whether a replacement is covered.
    • βœ“ If the other driver was at fault, ask their insurer to include the seat in the property damage claim.
    • βœ“ Keep proof. Save the receipt for the new seat and photos of the old one in the vehicle.
    • βœ“ Mention NHTSA's guidance. If the crash wasn't minor under NHTSA's test, say so when you make your request.

    Even if insurance doesn't pay, replace the seat if the crash wasn't minor. A new car seat costs far less than the risk of using one that may fail.

    A real-life scenario

    Jade's fender bender

    Jade is stopped in traffic when another driver hits the back of her SUV. Her son is in his car seat behind her. Everyone is fine, and she drives home.

    That night, she runs through NHTSA's list. The SUV was driven away, no one was hurt, and the air bags didn't deploy. But the rear door next to her son's seat has a dent.

    Because one condition fails, she treats it as more than a minor crash and buys a new seat the next day.

    When she files her claim with the other driver's insurer, she includes the receipt and photos, and asks for the seat to be added to the claim.

    Illustrative example. Names are made up. Insurance outcomes depend on the policy and claim.

    What to do with the old seat

    1. Stop using it Don't use a seat from a crash that wasn't minor, even as a spare.
    2. Keep it until the claim is settled Your insurer may want to see it or photos of it.
    3. Make it unusable before disposal Cut the straps and mark it as crashed so no one else picks it up and uses it.
    4. Install the new seat carefully Follow the manual, and get help from a certified child passenger safety technician if you need it.

    Buying the replacement seat

    Once you've decided to replace the seat, a few steps help you get the right one quickly and keep your claim simple. Start by checking the label on the old seat for the model name and manufacture date, which helps you pick a comparable replacement and document the loss. Photograph the label before you get rid of the seat.

    Buy a new seat rather than a used one, since you can't be sure a used seat hasn't been in a crash. Choose one that fits your child's age, weight and height and fits your vehicle. Then keep the receipt with your claim paperwork. If your insurer agrees to cover the seat, it will usually want proof of what you paid.

    • βœ“ Photograph the old seat's label with the model and manufacture date.
    • βœ“ Buy new, not used, so you know its history.
    • βœ“ Match your child and vehicle when choosing the replacement.
    • βœ“ Keep the receipt for your insurance claim.

    Frequently asked questions

    Should I buy a used car seat after an accident?

    It's safer to buy new. You can't be sure a used seat hasn't been in a crash that weakened it.

    Does a car seat need replacing if my child wasn't in it during the crash?

    NHTSA's guidance is based on the crash itself, not whether a child was in the seat. Use the five conditions to decide.

    Do I need to replace a car seat after an accident?

    NHTSA recommends replacing car seats after a moderate or severe crash. A seat may not need replacing only if the crash meets all five of NHTSA's minor crash conditions.

    What counts as a minor crash for car seats?

    All five must be true: the vehicle could be driven away, the door nearest the seat wasn't damaged, no one was injured, the air bags didn't deploy, and the seat shows no visible damage.

    Does auto insurance pay for a new car seat after an accident?

    It depends on your policy and the claim. Ask the adjuster when you file, and keep the receipt and photos.

    Can I keep using a car seat that looks fine after a crash?

    Only if the crash meets all five of NHTSA's minor crash conditions. Damage can be hidden, so if any condition fails, replace it.

    What should I do with a car seat after a crash?

    Stop using it, keep it until your claim is settled, then make it unusable before you throw it away.

    Your next step

    See what you could pay

    Compare options available where you live, or call to talk it through with a licensed agent. Looking is free.

    ConnectingCrowd is an information site and is not affiliated with any government agency.

    Compare auto insurance options

    Sponsored

    See auto insurance options near you

    Rates and available coverages vary by state and insurer. Add your ZIP code to compare. It is free and you are not committing to anything.

    Find auto insurance that fits your loan or lease

    Sponsored
    Was this article helpful?

    Want coverage that protects your family?

    Compare auto insurance options where you live.