In 30 seconds
- Start with a budget. The CFPB advises planning holiday spending before you borrow.
- Buy now, pay later plans often split a purchase into four payments, with late fees if you miss one.
- Car title loans can carry a fee equal to about 300% APR and put your car at risk.
- Credit unions, community banks and a written plan to repay are safer starting points.
In this article
Holiday borrowing at a glance
- Typical BNPL plan: 4 payments, often every two weeks
- First BNPL payment: may be due at checkout
- Car title loan term: often 15 or 30 days
- Car title loan size: often 25% to 50% of the car's value
- 25% monthly title loan fee: about 300% APR
Sources: CFPB on buy now, pay later; FTC on car title loans.
Start with a number, not a loan
Before comparing loans, decide what the holidays should cost you. The CFPB's advice for holiday shoppers is to budget first: work out what you can afford, then decide how to pay. A loan doesn't make gifts cheaper. It spreads the cost into January, February and beyond, often with fees or interest added.
A simple list helps: names, a gift limit for each, travel, food and events. Compare the total with what you can pay from this month's income and savings. Only the gap, if there is one, is worth borrowing for.
Buy now, pay later: convenient, with fine print
Buy now, pay later (BNPL) is the checkout button that splits a purchase into smaller payments. The CFPB says a common plan is four interest-free payments made every two weeks, and the first payment may be due at checkout. Eligibility is usually simple: the CFPB says you generally need to be 18, have a mobile number and link a debit card, credit card or bank account.
- β Late fees. The CFPB says most BNPL lenders charge late fees if you miss a payment.
- β Returns don't always stop payments. The CFPB warns that even if you return an item, you may need to keep paying until the return is processed.
- β Credit reporting varies. Payment history may or may not be reported to credit bureaus, and missed payments could hurt your scores.
- β Stacking adds up. Several small plans across different apps can mean several payments landing in the same week.
The CFPB suggests considering autopay so you don't miss a payment, but only if you're sure the money will be in your account. An autopay that bounces can trigger bank fees on top of late fees.
Car title loans: the most expensive holiday cash
A car title loan uses your vehicle as collateral. The FTC says these loans usually last 15 or 30 days and are often for 25% to 50% of the car's value. The cost is steep. The FTC gives an example: a 25% monthly fee works out to an annual percentage rate (APR) of about 300%. Borrowing $1,000 for a month means owing $1,250.
The bigger risk is losing your car. The FTC warns that a lender may repossess your vehicle if you don't repay, even if you've made partial payments. For many families, losing the car means losing the way to get to work, which is a far bigger problem than a lean holiday.
Comparing your options
The table below sums up how common holiday borrowing options compare, using what the CFPB and FTC publish. Costs vary by lender, so always read the loan terms and the APR before you sign.
| Option | How it works | Main risk |
|---|---|---|
| Buy now, pay later | Often 4 payments every two weeks, first one at checkout | Late fees, overlapping payments, returns that don't pause payments |
| Personal loan | A fixed amount repaid in monthly installments | Interest and fees add to the cost. Compare APRs from several lenders. |
| Credit union or community bank loan | The FTC lists these as alternatives to title loans | Approval depends on your credit and the lender's rules |
| Car title loan | Short loan, often 15 or 30 days, using your car as collateral | About 300% APR at a 25% monthly fee, and possible repossession |
Sources: CFPB on buy now, pay later; FTC on car title loans.
Safer alternatives to consider
The FTC suggests that people short on cash look at alternatives before a title loan. These include a small loan from a credit union or community bank, help from family, or local charities and community groups. Many credit unions offer small-dollar loans designed as an alternative to high-cost short-term loans.
Other options cost nothing at all: a gift exchange instead of individual presents, a cap on family spending, homemade gifts, or traveling a week earlier when fares may differ. A holiday that's paid for by New Year's Day usually feels better in February than one that isn't.
Questions to ask any holiday lender
Whatever kind of loan you consider, a few direct questions will tell you a lot about the true cost. A reputable lender should answer them clearly and in writing.
- β What is the APR, including all fees, not just the interest rate?
- β What is the total amount I'll repay, and on which dates?
- β What happens, and what does it cost, if a payment is late?
- β Will this loan be reported to credit bureaus?
- β Can I repay early without a penalty?
If a lender pressures you to sign right away or won't give you the terms in writing, walk away and compare other offers.
A real-life scenario
Andre's $1,000 holiday gap
Andre budgets $1,600 for gifts and travel, but has only $600 set aside. He sees two quick options: a title loan on his car, or splitting purchases across a few BNPL plans.
Using the FTC's example, a $1,000 title loan with a 25% monthly fee would cost $250 for a single month, and his car would be on the line. He passes.
He trims his list to $1,200, puts $600 toward it now, and splits one $400 purchase into four $100 BNPL payments that his paychecks can cover. He sets a phone reminder for each due date.
This is an illustration, not a recommendation of any product. Your costs depend on the lender and the terms you're offered.
Illustrative example. Names and numbers are made up to show how it works.
Before you borrow for the holidays
- Write the budget Know your total and the gap you're trying to fill.
- Check the full cost Look at the APR, fees and late charges, not only the payment size.
- Map the due dates List every payment on a calendar, including BNPL installments.
- Avoid putting your car at risk A title loan can cost about 300% APR and lead to repossession.
- Plan the payoff Decide which paychecks will repay the loan before you sign.
Frequently asked questions
What is a holiday loan?
It's usually a personal loan or short-term credit marketed for holiday spending. It works like any other loan: you repay it with interest or fees, so compare the APR and terms before you borrow.
Is buy now, pay later a good idea for holiday gifts?
It can work if you can afford every payment. The CFPB warns about late fees, overlapping plans and returns that don't stop payments right away.
How expensive is a car title loan?
Very. The FTC says a 25% monthly fee works out to about 300% APR, and the lender may repossess your car if you don't repay.
What are safer alternatives?
The FTC suggests credit unions, community banks, family and local charities. Cutting the holiday budget also costs nothing.
Ready to compare loan options?
Compare options available where you live, or call to talk it through with a licensed agent. Looking is free.
ConnectingCrowd is an information site and is not affiliated with any government agency.
Compare personal loan options
SponsoredRelated guides
See all personal loans guides
Buy now, pay later or a personal loan? How they really compare
Payday alternative loans: a lower-cost small loan from federal credit unions
Car title loans: the real cost, the risks and safer ways to borrow
Home improvement loans: the five ways to pay for a remodel, and how to pick one
Hard vs soft credit inquiries: which ones affect your score, and how to shop for a loan without worry
How to compare personal loan offers without getting fooled by the monthly paymentSee loan options in your state
Loan options vary by state and lender. Enter your ZIP code to compare options. Looking is free.
Compare loan options for your situation
SponsoredSources
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is based on publicly available sources, which may be incomplete, outdated or incorrect. It is not legal, financial, insurance, tax or medical advice. ConnectingCrowd is not affiliated with any government agency, insurer or lender. Please do your own research and talk to a licensed professional before making any decision.
