In 30 seconds
- Loans secured by your home (home equity loans, HELOCs, cash-out refinances) often cost less, but you could lose your home if you can't repay.
- Unsecured options such as personal loans and credit lines don't use your home, but the CFPB says limits may be lower and rates higher.
- Never take financing your contractor arranges without shopping around and comparing loan terms, the FTC warns.
- Don't pay the full project cost up front. Some states limit how much a contractor can ask for as a down payment.
In this article
Your options at a glance
- Personal loan: unsecured, fixed payments
- Home equity loan: lump sum, regular payments, secured by your home
- HELOC: borrow as you go, usually variable rate
- Cash-out refinance: replaces your mortgage
- Credit card: fastest, usually the highest rate
Based on CFPB descriptions of home equity products and alternatives.
The big decision: secured or unsecured
The CFPB compares home equity borrowing with alternatives that don't use your home. Its takeaway: options that use your home as collateral can come with lower rates, while a personal line of credit may have lower limits and higher rates. The trade-off is risk. On a HELOC, the CFPB warns that if you fall behind or can't repay the loan on schedule, you could lose your home.
| Option | Uses your home? | How you get money | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Personal loan | No | Lump sum, fixed monthly payments | Rates depend heavily on your credit |
| Home equity loan | Yes | Borrow all of it up front, repay in regular monthly payments | Closing costs; repayment often required when you sell |
| HELOC | Yes | Borrow, spend and repay as you go during a draw period | Variable rate; payments can rise in the repayment period |
| Cash-out refinance | Yes | New, bigger mortgage; you get the difference in cash | Closing costs; a higher rate on your whole mortgage |
| Credit card | No | Charge up to your limit | Regular card rates are typically higher than home-secured options |
Source: CFPB, What other types of loans are similar to a HELOC?; CFPB HELOC brochure.
Option 1: a personal loan
A personal loan gives you a lump sum and a fixed payment schedule, and many are unsecured, so your house isn't on the line. It can be a good fit for mid-size projects, or for homeowners who don't have much equity yet.
The cost depends largely on your credit. Compare offers by APR, not just the monthly payment, and check for origination fees that come out of the money you receive. Our guides on comparing personal loan offers and unsecured personal loans explain what to look for.
Options 2 and 3: home equity loans and HELOCs
Both borrow against your equity, the part of the home's value you own outright. The CFPB describes the difference this way:
- β Home equity loan: you typically borrow all the money up front and repay it in regular monthly payments. The rate is generally fixed. If you need more later, you apply for a new loan.
- β HELOC: a line of credit you can borrow from, spend and repay as you go during the draw period, then pay back during a repayment period. The rate is usually variable: an index plus a margin the lender adds.
Costs can include appraisal fees, application fees and closing costs, though the CFPB notes some lenders waive some or all up-front costs. Under federal law you can cancel a HELOC for any reason within the first three days.
A HELOC can suit a remodel paid in stages, because you draw only what you need. Our personal loan vs HELOC comparison goes deeper.
Options 4 and 5: cash-out refinance and credit cards
A cash-out refinance replaces your mortgage with a larger one and pays you the difference. The CFPB says to carefully consider the interest rate, especially if it's higher than the rate on your current mortgage, because the new rate applies to your whole balance. Closing costs usually apply.
Credit cards are the quickest way to pay a contractor, and some offer a low promotional rate for a set time. But the CFPB notes regular card rates are typically higher than options that use your home as collateral. Cards work best for small jobs you can pay off quickly.
A real-life scenario
The Parks redo their kitchen
Dana and Chris Park have a $30,000 kitchen quote. They have plenty of home equity and good credit.
They compare three quotes: a personal loan, a fixed-rate home equity loan and a HELOC. They line up each offer's APR, fees and monthly payment on one sheet.
Their contractor offers 'easy financing through a lender I know.' Remembering the FTC's advice, they don't sign until they've compared it, and it turns out to have the highest APR of the four.
They choose the home equity loan for its fixed payment, agree to a modest deposit rather than paying everything up front, and hold the final payment until the job passes inspection.
Illustrative example. Names and numbers are made up to show how it works.
Contractor financing and scams: what the FTC warns
Home improvement is a common setting for scams, and financing is part of the playbook. The FTC says to watch for these red flags:
- β A contractor who says he can arrange financing through a lender he knows. Never agree to it without shopping around and comparing loan terms.
- β Pressure to decide immediately, or a door-to-door pitch because they're "in the area."
- β A demand to pay for everything up front, or to pay only in cash.
- β A request that you get the building permits yourself.
- β Any request to sign over your deed. The FTC says never transfer your deed without consulting an attorney.
The FTC has described homeowners who later found they'd agreed to a home equity loan with a high interest rate, points and fees, while the work went unfinished. Get a written contract with the contractor's license number, start and completion dates and every promise, and make sure no blanks are left. If you sign at your home rather than at the seller's place of business, the contract should include your right to cancel within three business days.
Before you sign: a quick checklist
- β Get at least three written bids for the work itself.
- β Get loan quotes from more than one lender and compare APRs and total fees.
- β Decide whether you're comfortable putting your home up as collateral.
- β Keep the down payment small and the final payment until the job is done right.
- β Talk to a HUD-approved housing counselor (1-800-569-4287) if you're weighing home equity options, as the CFPB suggests.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best loan for home improvements?
It depends on your equity, credit and risk tolerance. Home equity loans and HELOCs often have lower rates but put your home at risk. Personal loans don't use your home but may cost more.
Can I use a personal loan for home improvements?
Yes. Many people use unsecured personal loans for remodels. Compare APRs and fees across lenders.
Is a HELOC a good idea for a remodel?
It can be, especially for projects paid in stages. The CFPB notes HELOC rates are usually variable and that you could lose your home if you can't repay.
Should I use my contractor's financing?
Only after comparing it with other offers. The FTC says never agree to financing through your contractor without shopping around.
Can I cancel a home equity line of credit?
Yes. The CFPB says federal law lets you cancel a HELOC for any reason within the first three days.
Ready to compare loan options?
Compare options available where you live, or call to talk it through with a licensed agent. Looking is free.
ConnectingCrowd is an information site and is not affiliated with any government agency.
Compare personal loan options
SponsoredRelated guides
See all personal loans guides
Personal loan vs HELOC: borrowing against your credit or against your home
How to compare personal loan offers without getting fooled by the monthly payment
Unsecured personal loans: borrowing on your credit alone
Hard vs soft credit inquiries: which ones affect your score, and how to shop for a loan without worry
Rent-to-own and lease-to-own: how they work and what they can cost you
How to build credit from scratch, step by stepSee loan options in your state
Loan options vary by state and lender. Enter your ZIP code to compare options. Looking is free.
Compare loan options for your situation
SponsoredSources
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is based on publicly available sources, which may be incomplete, outdated or incorrect. It is not legal, financial, insurance, tax or medical advice. ConnectingCrowd is not affiliated with any government agency, insurer or lender. Please do your own research and talk to a licensed professional before making any decision.
