Personal Loans Β· Shopping

How to compare personal loan offers without getting fooled by the monthly payment

Two loans with the same monthly payment can cost very different amounts. Federal Truth in Lending rules require lenders to show you standard numbers before you sign, so you can line offers up side by side. Here is what each number means.

Fact-checked against the CFPB's Regulation Z (Truth in Lending) and MyCreditUnion.gov. Every source is listed at the end of this article.
Person using a calculator at a desk
PERSONAL LOANS GUIDEAPRThe cost of your credit as a yearly rate

In 30 seconds

  • Lenders must disclose the amount financed, finance charge, APR, payment schedule and total of payments.
  • APR is described in the rules as the cost of your credit as a yearly rate, so it includes more than the interest rate.
  • The total of payments shows what you will have paid after all scheduled payments.
  • Also check for late fees, prepayment penalties and whether the loan is secured.
In this article

    The disclosure numbers to compare

    • Amount financed: the credit actually provided to you
    • Finance charge: the dollar amount the credit will cost you
    • APR: the cost of your credit as a yearly rate
    • Total of payments: what you'll have paid after all scheduled payments

    Wording from the CFPB's Regulation Z, section 1026.18.

    The numbers lenders must show you

    TermWhat it meansWhy it matters
    Amount financedThe amount of credit provided to you or on your behalfCan be less than the loan amount if fees are taken out first
    Finance chargeThe dollar amount the credit will cost youYour total borrowing cost in dollars
    APRThe cost of your credit as a yearly rateBest single number for comparing loans of the same length
    Payment scheduleNumber, amounts and timing of paymentsShows whether you can afford each payment
    Total of paymentsWhat you will have paid when you have made all scheduled paymentsShows the full cost of a longer term

    Definitions from Regulation Z section 1026.18, the federal Truth in Lending rule for closed-end loans.

    Why the monthly payment can mislead you

    A longer loan term lowers the monthly payment but usually raises the total you pay. That is why the total of payments and the finance charge matter as much as the payment itself.

    Offer AOffer B
    Loan amount$10,000$10,000
    Term36 months60 months
    Monthly paymentHigherLower
    Total of paymentsLowerHigher

    Illustrative comparison. Always use the actual disclosure numbers from each lender.

    Compare the same term

    APR is most useful when you compare loans with the same length. If the terms differ, look at the total of payments too.

    Other terms to check before you sign

    • βœ“ Prepayment: the disclosure must say whether there is a penalty for paying early
    • βœ“ Late payment: any fee or percentage charged when a payment is late
    • βœ“ Security interest: whether the lender takes collateral, such as a vehicle or savings
    • βœ“ Variable rate: if the rate can rise, how and how much
    • βœ“ Origination or other upfront fees, which can reduce the amount financed

    MyCreditUnion.gov also advises knowing the total finance charge, including all interest and fees you must pay to get the loan, before you sign.

    A simple way to compare

    1. Collect offers for the same amount and term. This makes APR comparisons fair.
    2. Write down the APR, finance charge and total of payments for each. These come from the disclosure.
    3. Check the amount financed. Make sure fees are not eating into the money you actually get.
    4. Look at the fine print. Prepayment, late fees and collateral.
    5. Pick the lowest total cost you can afford monthly. Not just the lowest payment.

    The cheaper-looking loan

    Luis had two offers for $8,000. One had a lower monthly payment, but it ran two years longer.

    When he compared the total of payments on each disclosure, the longer loan cost him over a thousand dollars more, so he chose the shorter one.

    Illustrative example. Names and numbers are made up to show how it works.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the best way to compare personal loans?

    Compare the APR for loans with the same term, then check the finance charge and total of payments on each lender's disclosure.

    Is APR the same as the interest rate?

    No. Regulation Z describes APR as the cost of your credit as a yearly rate, which can include certain fees in addition to interest.

    Do lenders have to tell me about prepayment penalties?

    Yes. The federal disclosure must state whether a penalty may be charged if you pay the loan off early.

    What is the amount financed?

    The amount of credit provided to you or on your behalf. If fees are taken out of the loan, it can be less than the amount you borrow.

    Your next step

    Compare personal loan options

    Compare options available where you live, or call to talk it through with a licensed agent. Looking is free.

    ConnectingCrowd is an information site and is not affiliated with any government agency.

    Compare personal loan offers

    Sponsored

    Keep exploring personal loans

    Other topics:MedicareAuto insuranceLife insuranceHome insuranceDebt reliefAll guides

    See loan options in your state

    Loan options vary by state and lender. Enter your ZIP code to compare options. Looking is free.

    Compare loan options for your situation

    Sponsored
    Was this article helpful?

    Ready to compare loans?

    Look at the full cost, not just the monthly payment.