Auto Insurance Β· Claims

Diminished value claims: when you can be paid for the value your car lost in an accident

Even after a perfect repair, a car with an accident on its record can be worth less when you sell or trade it in. That lost value is called diminished value. Whether you can be paid for it depends mostly on one thing: whose insurance you're claiming against. Regulators in Texas and Idaho say your own insurer generally doesn't have to pay it, but the at-fault driver's insurer may. Here's how diminished value works, when it's paid, and how to make a strong claim.

Fact-checked against the Texas Department of Insurance and the Idaho Department of Insurance. Every source is listed at the end of this article.
Worker applying film to an orange car in a shop
AUTO INSURANCE GUIDEThird partyDiminished value claims are usually made against the at-fault driver's insurer

In 30 seconds

  • Diminished value is the loss in a car's market value after an accident, as Idaho's insurance department describes it.
  • Texas says your own insurer isn't obligated to pay diminished value when your car is completely repaired to its pre-damage condition.
  • Texas says the at-fault driver's insurer may have to pay a third-party claimant for lost market value, regardless of how well the car was repaired.
  • In Texas, uninsured motorist coverage can also pay diminished value.
  • Idaho says insurers aren't obligated to pay diminished value unless your policy says so.
In this article

    Diminished value at a glance

    • What it is: lost market value after an accident
    • Your own collision coverage: generally doesn't pay it
    • At-fault driver's insurer: may have to pay it
    • Texas uninsured motorist coverage: can pay it
    • Proof: appraisals, dealer quotes, repair records

    Sources: Texas Department of Insurance; Idaho Department of Insurance.

    What diminished value means

    The Idaho Department of Insurance describes diminished value as generally used to describe the loss in the market value of your vehicle after an accident. Buyers often pay less for a car with a reported accident, even if it was fixed well. That difference is what a diminished value claim tries to recover.

    Claims against your own insurer

    In Texas, a 2000 bulletin from the Texas Department of Insurance says an insurer isn't obligated to pay a first-party claimant for diminished value when the car is completely repaired to its pre-damage condition. The bulletin explains that the policy language doesn't require payment for, or refer to, diminished value.

    Under the standard Texas policy, collision and other-than-collision coverage pay the lesser of the car's actual cash value, the amount to repair or replace it with property of like kind and quality, or the amount on your declarations page, minus your deductible. The Idaho Department of Insurance takes a similar view: your insurer isn't obligated to pay diminished value unless your policy contract says it will.

    Read your policy

    A few policies or states may treat this differently. Check your policy language, and call your state insurance department if you're unsure.

    Claims against the at-fault driver's insurer

    This is where diminished value is most often paid. The Texas Department of Insurance says an insurer may be obligated to pay a third-party claimant for any loss of market value of their car, regardless of how complete the repair was. In other words, if another driver caused the crash, you can ask their liability insurer to pay for your car's lost value along with the repairs.

    See our guide to filing a claim with the other driver's insurance for how third-party claims work.

    When uninsured motorist coverage pays

    If the at-fault driver has no insurance, or it's a hit-and-run, your own uninsured motorist coverage may step in. The Texas Department of Insurance says uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage pays diminished value if your car is worth less after the accident, and its 2000 bulletin says an insurer may be obligated to pay loss of market value under that coverage. Our guide to hit-and-run accidents covers that situation.

    Who you claim againstWill diminished value be paid?
    Your own collision coverageGenerally no in Texas and Idaho, unless your policy says so
    At-fault driver's liability insurerMay be paid, per Texas
    Your uninsured motorist coverage (Texas)Can pay diminished value

    Based on Texas and Idaho regulator guidance. Rules vary by state.

    How to support a diminished value claim

    1. Finish the repairs first Diminished value is measured after the car is fixed.
    2. Keep every record Save the repair estimate, final invoice, photos and parts list.
    3. Get value estimates Ask dealers what they'd offer for the car now and what they'd have offered before the accident.
    4. Consider an independent appraisal An appraiser who specializes in vehicle values can write a report. You'll usually pay for it.
    5. Send a written demand Send the insurer your evidence and the amount you're asking for.

    Be ready to negotiate. Insurers may use their own methods to value the loss, and you may disagree.

    What can make the loss larger

    • βœ“ A newer car with low mileage, where an accident history matters more to buyers.
    • βœ“ Structural or frame damage, compared with cosmetic damage.
    • βœ“ A vehicle that held its value well before the accident.

    Older cars with high mileage may lose less value from an accident, which can make a claim less worthwhile.

    Other claim rights worth knowing

    The Idaho Department of Insurance notes that you might not be obligated to use an insurer's preferred repair shop, though you might pay the difference if your shop charges more than others nearby. If an insurer specifies non-original crash parts, it must tell you in writing, and you may have to pay the difference for original manufacturer parts. Idaho also says no one, including a repair shop, may pay or waive your deductible for you.

    If the insurer says no

    If you and the at-fault driver's insurer can't agree, you can ask for a written explanation, provide more evidence, or contact your state insurance department. The Idaho Department of Insurance notes that disputes over fault might need to be resolved through the courts. For a large loss, some people talk to an attorney. Our guide to a denied auto insurance claim walks through your options.

    The bottom line

    Diminished value is real money, but it's usually paid by the at-fault driver's insurer, not your own. Texas and Idaho say your own insurer generally doesn't owe it after a complete repair, while a third-party claim or Texas uninsured motorist coverage may pay. Document the repair, get value estimates, and send a written demand.

    Frequently asked questions

    Do I have to use the insurer's preferred repair shop?

    Not necessarily. The Idaho Department of Insurance says you might not be obligated to, but you might pay the difference if your shop charges more than others in the area.

    Does collision coverage pay diminished value?

    Generally not. The Texas Department of Insurance says the standard policy pays the lesser of actual cash value, the cost to repair or replace with like kind and quality, or the declarations amount, minus your deductible.

    Can a repair shop waive my deductible?

    Not in Idaho. The Idaho Department of Insurance says no other party, including a repair shop, may pay or waive your deductible.

    What is a diminished value claim?

    A claim for the loss in your car's market value after an accident, even after repairs.

    Will my own insurance pay diminished value?

    Generally not in Texas or Idaho. Texas says insurers aren't obligated to pay first-party diminished value when a car is completely repaired, and Idaho says not unless your policy says so.

    Can I claim diminished value from the other driver's insurance?

    Yes, in many cases. Texas says an insurer may be obligated to pay a third-party claimant for lost market value regardless of repair quality.

    Does uninsured motorist coverage pay diminished value?

    In Texas, yes. TDI lists diminished value among the things uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage pays.

    How do I prove diminished value?

    Keep repair records and get value estimates from dealers or an independent appraiser showing what the car is worth now compared with before the accident.

    Your next step

    See what you could pay

    Compare options available where you live, or call to talk it through with a licensed agent. Looking is free.

    ConnectingCrowd is an information site and is not affiliated with any government agency.

    Compare auto insurance options

    Sponsored

    See auto insurance options near you

    Rates and available coverages vary by state and insurer. Add your ZIP code to compare. It is free and you are not committing to anything.

    Find auto insurance that fits your loan or lease

    Sponsored
    Was this article helpful?

    Want better protection?

    Compare auto insurance quotes with uninsured motorist coverage.