Auto Insurance Β· Claims

Auto insurance claim denied? How to find out why, push back and get help

Few letters are as frustrating as a claim denial after an accident. You paid your premiums, and now the company says no. Sometimes the denial is correct: the damage isn't covered by your policy. Sometimes it's a mistake, a misunderstanding or a missing document. Either way, you have more options than most people realize. Here's what to do, step by step, based on guidance from the Georgia Office of Insurance and Safety Fire Commissioner and the NAIC.

Fact-checked against the Georgia Office of Commissioner of Insurance and the NAIC. Every source is listed at the end of this article.
Frustrated man shouting into a telephone handset
AUTO INSURANCE GUIDEFreeThe cost to file a complaint with your state insurance department, per the NAIC

In 30 seconds

  • Ask for a written letter explaining the reason for the denial and the policy language it's based on.
  • Read your policy's coverages, exclusions and deductibles, and compare them with the reason given.
  • Keep copies of all letters and a log of every call: the date, the person's name and title, and what was said.
  • Don't make permanent repairs before the damage is inspected. Georgia's regulator says that can lead to a denial.
  • If you can't resolve it, your state insurance department can investigate unfair delays or denials for free.
In this article

    Your next steps after a denial

    • 1. Get the denial reason in writing
    • 2. Compare it with your policy
    • 3. Gather evidence and records
    • 4. Ask the insurer to reconsider
    • 5. File a free complaint with your state

    Sources: Georgia Office of Commissioner of Insurance, Insurance claim tips; NAIC, How do I file a complaint?

    Common reasons auto claims are denied

    Denials often come down to a handful of issues. The damage may not be covered by the coverages you bought. For example, damage to your own car from a crash needs collision coverage, and liability-only policies don't include it. The driver may not be listed on the policy. The claim may have been reported late, since Georgia's regulator notes that your policy might require you to report a claim within a certain time. Or the insurer may say information was incomplete or inconsistent.

    Possible reasonWhat to check
    Coverage not on your policyYour declarations page and the coverages you bought
    Excluded lossThe exclusions section of your policy
    Late noticeWhen you reported the claim and what your policy requires
    Disputed facts or faultPolice report, photos and witness statements
    Missing informationWhat the insurer asked for and what you sent

    General guide only. Your policy and your state law control.

    Step 1: Get the reason in writing

    A phone call isn't enough. Georgia's insurance regulator says that if a disagreement leads to a denial, you should ask for a written letter explaining the reason for the denial, along with the specific policy language the company relied on. With the reason and the exact wording in front of you, you can judge whether the denial holds up.

    Step 2: Read your policy

    Georgia's regulator advises knowing what's covered, what's excluded and what your deductibles are. Start with your declarations page to see which coverages you bought, then read the section of the policy the denial letter cites. Sometimes the language is clear. Sometimes it's open to more than one reading, which is worth raising with the company.

    Step 3: Gather your evidence

    • βœ“ The police report and report number.
    • βœ“ Photos and video of the damage and the scene.
    • βœ“ Repair estimates, receipts and medical bills.
    • βœ“ Witness names and contact details.
    • βœ“ Every letter and email from the insurer.
    • βœ“ A log of each call or visit: date, name and title, and what was said.

    Georgia's regulator stresses keeping copies of all correspondence and a record of every contact, plus a record of your time and expenses. Complete, correct information avoids delays.

    Don't fix it too fast

    Make only temporary repairs to prevent more damage, keep the receipts, and photograph the damage first. Georgia's regulator warns that a company may deny a claim if you make permanent repairs before the damage is inspected.

    Step 4: Ask the insurer to reconsider

    Write to the adjuster or claims supervisor. Explain why you believe the claim should be paid, point to the policy language that supports you, and attach your evidence. Ask for a written response. If the dispute is about the amount rather than the denial itself, Georgia's regulator suggests asking the adjuster for an itemized explanation of the settlement offer and not rushing into a settlement.

    Step 5: File a complaint with your state

    If you can't resolve it with the company, the NAIC says you can file a complaint with your state department of insurance. It recommends trying to resolve the issue with the insurer first. State departments can investigate issues such as unfair claim delays or denials, failure to honor your policy, lack of timely communication, and violations of state insurance laws, at no cost to you.

    The NAIC suggests including your policy number, your documents and records, a log of all communication with dates and times, a detailed factual account, the policy language involved where possible, and the outcome you want. Most departments accept complaints online, by mail or by phone. The department forwards your complaint to the insurer, which must respond, and the insurer can't discriminate against you for filing.

    When to get more help

    If the claim involves serious injuries, a large amount of money or a disputed lawsuit, consider talking with an attorney. Georgia's regulator also suggests seeking professional advice if you're unsure whether a settlement offer is fair. If the other driver's insurer denied your claim, our guide to filing with the other driver's insurance explains your options, including using your own coverage.

    How to avoid a denial next time

    1. Report claims promptly Check your policy for any notice deadline.
    2. Keep your policy current List every driver and vehicle, and review your coverage at renewal.
    3. Document everything Photos, a police report and witness details make claims easier to prove.
    4. Be accurate Give complete, correct information. Mistakes cause delays.

    If you disagree with the amount, not the denial

    Sometimes the company pays, but less than you think the repair or your car is worth. Ask for an itemized explanation of how the offer was calculated, and compare it with your own repair estimates or prices for similar vehicles in your area. Georgia's regulator also suggests giving the adjuster records of any improvements, such as new tires or recent major repairs, that could raise the value.

    Don't feel pressured to accept the first offer. Georgia's regulator advises not rushing into a settlement and being prepared to negotiate.

    The bottom line

    A denied auto claim isn't always the final word. Get the reason and policy language in writing, compare it with your policy, gather your evidence and ask the company to reconsider. If that fails, your state insurance department can review the denial for free.

    Frequently asked questions

    What should I do if my auto insurance claim is denied?

    Ask for a written explanation and the policy language behind it, review your policy, gather evidence, ask the insurer to reconsider, and file a complaint with your state if needed.

    Can I appeal a denied auto insurance claim?

    You can ask the company to reconsider in writing with your evidence. If that fails, your state insurance department can investigate unfair denials.

    Is it free to file a complaint with the insurance department?

    Yes. The NAIC says state insurance departments investigate complaints such as unfair claim denials at no cost.

    Can an insurer deny a claim if I fix my car first?

    It can. Georgia's regulator warns that permanent repairs before the damage is inspected may lead to a denial. Make temporary repairs and keep receipts.

    Why would an auto claim be denied?

    Common reasons include the loss not being covered, an exclusion, late notice, disputed facts or missing information.

    Your next step

    See what you could pay

    Compare options available where you live, or call to talk it through with a licensed agent. Looking is free.

    ConnectingCrowd is an information site and is not affiliated with any government agency.

    Compare auto insurance options

    Sponsored

    See auto insurance options near you

    Rates and available coverages vary by state and insurer. Add your ZIP code to compare. It is free and you are not committing to anything.

    Find auto insurance that fits your loan or lease

    Sponsored
    Was this article helpful?

    Want coverage that fits?

    Compare auto insurance quotes with the coverage you actually need.