Auto Insurance Β· Coverage

Comprehensive vs collision coverage: which one pays for what

Comprehensive and collision are the two coverages that pay to fix your own vehicle. They are often sold together as part of full coverage, but they protect against very different things. Here is how to tell them apart.

Fact-checked against the NAIC and the California Department of Insurance. Every source is listed at the end of this article.
Deer crossing a forest road
AUTO INSURANCE GUIDE2 coveragesThat pay to repair your own vehicle

In 30 seconds

  • Collision pays for damage when your vehicle hits another vehicle or an object, hits a pothole or rolls over.
  • Comprehensive pays for damage not caused by a collision, such as theft, hail, windstorm, flood, fire, vandalism or hitting an animal.
  • Both pay based on your vehicle's market value, minus your deductible.
  • If you have an auto loan or lease, your lender usually requires both.
In this article

    Quick way to remember

    • Collision: your vehicle crashes into something
    • Comprehensive: almost everything else that damages your vehicle
    • Neither pays for injuries or for other people's property
    • A higher deductible usually means a lower premium

    Based on the NAIC and the California Department of Insurance.

    Side by side

    CollisionComprehensive
    What it coversDamage from hitting another vehicle or object, a pothole, or rolling overDamage not caused by a collision
    ExamplesRear-ending another vehicle, hitting a guardrail or treeTheft, hail, windstorm, flood, fire, vandalism, hitting a deer
    Who was at fault matters?No, it pays for your vehicle either wayNo
    DeductibleYesYes, often a separate amount
    Required by law?NoNo
    Required by lender?Usually, if you finance or leaseUsually, if you finance or lease

    Based on NAIC and California Department of Insurance consumer guides.

    How the payout works

    The California Department of Insurance explains that collision and comprehensive pay based on the market value of your vehicle. You pay your deductible first. In its example, with a $500 comprehensive deductible and $1,500 of storm damage, you pay the first $500 and the coverage pays the other $1,000.

    Hail on Tuesday, a fender bender on Friday

    A hailstorm dented Aisha's hood and roof. That was a comprehensive claim, with her $500 comprehensive deductible.

    Later that week she backed into a pole in a parking lot. That one went under collision, with her separate collision deductible.

    Illustrative example. Names and numbers are made up to show how it works.

    Do you need both?

    Neither coverage is required by state law, but the NAIC notes that if you have an auto loan, your lender requires full coverage, which means both comprehensive and collision. Leases usually have the same rule.

    Once your vehicle is paid off, it is your choice. The California Department of Insurance suggests thinking about dropping comprehensive and/or collision on an older vehicle. A simple test: compare what you pay each year for the coverage with what the vehicle is worth, and ask whether you could afford to repair or replace it yourself.

    • βœ“ You still owe money on the vehicle or lease it: keep both
    • βœ“ Your vehicle is newer or valuable: both are usually worth it
    • βœ“ You live where hail, flooding or theft is common: comprehensive matters more
    • βœ“ Your vehicle is older and low in value: compare the premium with its value

    Choosing your deductibles

    California's guide says you usually pay a lower premium with a higher deductible. Pick a deductible you could pay on short notice without borrowing. Many insurers let you choose different deductibles for comprehensive and collision.

    Ask about glass

    Some insurers offer options for windshield and glass damage under comprehensive. Ask what yours includes.

    Frequently asked questions

    Does comprehensive cover hitting a deer?

    Yes. The NAIC lists hitting an animal as a comprehensive claim, not collision.

    Does collision cover hitting a pothole?

    Yes. The NAIC says collision covers damage from a collision with another vehicle, an object or a pothole, or from flipping over.

    Is full coverage the same as comprehensive?

    No. Full coverage usually means liability plus both comprehensive and collision.

    Should I drop collision on an older vehicle?

    It can make sense. The California Department of Insurance suggests considering dropping comprehensive and/or collision on an older vehicle. Compare the yearly cost with the vehicle's value.

    Your next step

    Compare coverage and deductibles

    Compare options available where you live, or call to talk it through with a licensed agent. Looking is free.

    ConnectingCrowd is an information site and is not affiliated with any government agency.

    Compare auto insurance quotes

    Sponsored

    Other auto insurance guides

    Other topics:MedicarePersonal loansLife insuranceHome insuranceDebt reliefAll guides

    See auto insurance options near you

    Rates and available coverages vary by state and insurer. Add your ZIP code to compare. It is free and you are not committing to anything.

    Find auto insurance that fits your loan or lease

    Sponsored
    Was this article helpful?

    Want the right mix of coverage?

    Compare comprehensive, collision and deductible options where you live.