Personal Loans Β· Rates

Fixed vs. variable rate loans: how they work and how to choose

When you borrow, one of the first choices you face is whether the interest rate stays the same for the life of the loan or can change over time. A fixed rate gives you a payment you can count on. A variable rate may start lower but can rise, sometimes a lot. Most personal loans have fixed rates, but variable rates show up in lines of credit, some private student loans and adjustable-rate mortgages. Here's how variable rates are set and limited, using the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's (CFPB) explanations, and how to decide which is right for you.

Fact-checked against the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB). Every source is listed at the end of this article.
Rising line graph over a city skyline
PERSONAL LOANS GUIDEIndex + marginHow a variable interest rate is usually calculated

In 30 seconds

  • A fixed rate stays the same for the whole loan, so your payment is predictable.
  • A variable rate is usually an index that moves with the market plus a margin set by the lender.
  • Rate caps limit how much a variable rate can change at each adjustment and over the life of the loan.
  • Before choosing a variable rate, ask the lender for the worst-case payment under the caps.
In this article

    How variable rates are built

    • Index: an interest rate that moves with market conditions
    • Margin: points the lender adds to the index
    • Margin: set in your agreement and won't change after closing
    • Caps: limit how much the rate can change
    • Common ARM lifetime cap: 5 percentage points

    From the CFPB pages on index and margin and on rate caps (adjustable-rate mortgages).

    Fixed rate vs. variable rate at a glance

    Fixed rateVariable rate
    Interest rateStays the same for the life of the loanCan go up or down over time
    Monthly paymentPredictableCan change when the rate changes
    Starting rateOften a bit higherOften lower at first
    Best forTight budgets and long loansShort payoff plans or if you can absorb higher payments

    General comparison. Your actual offers depend on the lender and your credit.

    Most personal loans come with fixed rates, which is part of their appeal. Variable rates are more common with home equity lines of credit, personal lines of credit, some private student loans and adjustable-rate mortgages.

    How a variable rate is set: index plus margin

    The CFPB explains variable rates through adjustable-rate mortgages, but the same building blocks apply to many variable-rate loans:

    • βœ“ The index is an interest rate that fluctuates with general market conditions. You don't control it, and neither does your lender.
    • βœ“ The margin is the number of percentage points the lender adds to the index to set your rate. The CFPB says it's set in your loan agreement and won't change after closing.
    • βœ“ Index plus margin is called the fully indexed rate. Your actual rate is that number, subject to any caps.
    Shop the margin

    The CFPB says margins can vary a lot between lenders and can be negotiated. Pay attention to the margin when you compare offers, not just the starting rate.

    Rate caps: how much your rate can change

    Caps put limits on how far a variable rate can move. For adjustable-rate mortgages, the CFPB describes three common kinds:

    CapWhat it limitsCommon example
    Initial adjustment capHow much the rate can change the first time it adjusts2 or 5 percentage points
    Subsequent adjustment capHow much it can change at each later adjustment1 or 2 percentage points
    Lifetime capHow far it can ever move from the starting rate5 percentage points

    Source: CFPB, What is a rate cap? Some loans have higher caps, and some set a floor on how low the rate can go.

    The CFPB points out that two lenders can offer the same starting rate with different caps. That makes caps one of the most important things to compare.

    What a rate change can do to your payment

    Carmen's line of credit

    Carmen opens a variable-rate line of credit to pay for a kitchen remodel. Her rate starts at the index plus a margin of 4 percentage points.

    Over the next two years, the index rises by 2 percentage points. Her margin stays the same, so her rate rises by 2 points too, and her monthly payment goes up.

    She'd planned her budget around the starting payment, so the increase squeezes her. She decides to pay down the balance faster before rates move again.

    Her friend took a fixed-rate personal loan for a similar project. His payment didn't change at all.

    Illustrative example. Names and numbers are made up to show how index changes flow into a variable rate.

    How to choose

    A variable rate isn't automatically bad, and a fixed rate isn't automatically better. It comes down to your budget and your timeline:

    • βœ“ Choose fixed if you need a payment you can count on, or if you'll be paying the loan off over several years.
    • βœ“ Consider variable if you plan to pay the balance off quickly, or if the starting rate is much lower and you could handle a higher payment.
    • βœ“ Ask for the worst case. The CFPB suggests asking what your payment would be if the rate rose as high as the caps allow.
    • βœ“ Read the disclosures. Lenders must show the APR and payment terms before you sign. For mortgages, you get a Loan Estimate within three business days of applying.

    Questions to ask a lender

    1. Is the rate fixed or variable? Get it in writing.
    2. If variable, what index and margin? Ask how often the rate adjusts.
    3. What are the caps? Ask for the initial, periodic and lifetime caps, and any floor.
    4. What's the highest my payment could be? Ask for the worst-case payment under the caps.
    5. Can I switch or refinance later? Ask about fees for paying off early or converting to a fixed rate.

    Variable rates on credit cards and lines of credit

    Variable rates aren't only for mortgages. Most credit cards and many lines of credit also have variable rates tied to an index. When the index rises, the rate on your balance can rise too, often without you doing anything differently. That's one reason credit card interest can creep up over time.

    A fixed-rate personal loan can be a way to lock in a rate if you're carrying a balance on a variable-rate card or line of credit. Whether it saves money depends on the loan's APR and fees compared with what you're paying now, and on whether you avoid running the card balance back up. Compare the total cost both ways before you decide.

    • βœ“ Check your statement to see whether your card or line of credit rate is variable.
    • βœ“ Compare APRs, including any origination fee on a new loan.
    • βœ“ Look at the total cost, not just the monthly payment.

    Frequently asked questions

    Do credit cards have variable rates?

    Most do. Card rates are often tied to an index, so they can rise or fall over time. Check your statement or card agreement.

    Can I switch from a variable rate to a fixed rate?

    Sometimes. You may be able to refinance into a fixed-rate loan, or some lines of credit offer a fixed-rate option. Ask about fees first.

    What's the difference between a fixed and a variable rate loan?

    A fixed rate stays the same for the life of the loan. A variable rate can change over time, usually because it's tied to an index that moves with the market.

    How is a variable interest rate calculated?

    It's usually an index plus a margin. The CFPB says the index moves with market conditions, and the margin is set in your loan agreement and won't change after closing.

    What is a rate cap?

    A cap limits how much a variable rate can change at each adjustment or over the life of the loan. For adjustable-rate mortgages, the CFPB says a lifetime cap of 5 percentage points is common.

    Are personal loans fixed or variable?

    Most personal loans have fixed rates, but some lenders offer variable rates. Lines of credit are more often variable. Check the loan terms.

    Is a variable rate ever a better deal?

    It can be if the starting rate is lower and you'll pay the loan off quickly. Ask for the worst-case payment before you decide.

    Your next step

    Ready to compare loan options?

    Compare options available where you live, or call to talk it through with a licensed agent. Looking is free.

    ConnectingCrowd is an information site and is not affiliated with any government agency.

    Compare personal loan options

    Sponsored

    See loan options in your state

    Loan options vary by state and lender. Enter your ZIP code to compare options. Looking is free.

    Compare loan options for your situation

    Sponsored
    Was this article helpful?

    Prefer a payment that never changes?

    Compare fixed-rate personal loan options.