In 30 seconds
- An auto loan is a secured loan: the CFPB says the lender holds title or an interest in the car until the loan is paid in full.
- Most personal loans are unsecured, so there's no collateral, and the CFPB says they may have a higher interest rate.
- Secured loans usually have lower interest rates, but you can lose the collateral if you don't pay.
- The CFPB suggests getting preapproved by a bank or other lender before you visit a dealer.
In this article
Secured vs unsecured
- Secured: property is used as collateral, like a car or home
- Lender's interest: held until the loan is paid in full
- Unsecured: no collateral; lender relies on your credit history
- Rates: secured usually lower; unsecured may be higher
- Car financing: dealer-arranged or direct from a bank or credit union
From CFPB, Differentiating between secured and unsecured loans (2022), and What is the difference between dealer-arranged and bank financing?
Secured vs. unsecured: the core difference
The CFPB defines secured loans as loans in which your property is used as collateral, something of value like a car, a boat or a home. With a secured loan, the lender holds title or an interest in the property until the loan is paid in full. Car loans are a common example.
An unsecured loan doesn't use property as collateral. The CFPB lists personal loans, most credit cards and student loans as examples. Because there's no collateral, lenders rely more on your credit history.
| Auto loan (secured) | Personal loan (usually unsecured) | |
|---|---|---|
| Collateral | The car | None |
| Interest rate | Usually lower (CFPB) | May be higher (CFPB) |
| If you don't pay | You can lose the car, plus credit damage and collections | Lender can't automatically take property, but credit damage, collections and lawsuits are possible |
| Who holds the title | Lender holds an interest until paid off | You own the car outright |
Based on CFPB educational materials. Your loan terms control.
Why an auto loan often costs less
The CFPB explains that secured loans usually have lower interest rates, and that because unsecured loans put lenders at higher risk, they may have a higher interest rate. For most buyers, that means an auto loan is the cheaper way to finance a car, especially a newer one.
Whatever loan you consider, compare the APR, which includes interest and certain fees. A lower monthly payment over a longer term can still cost more overall.
When a personal loan might make sense
A personal loan can be worth considering in some situations, such as:
- β An older or inexpensive car that some auto lenders won't finance.
- β A private-party sale where you want to pay the seller in cash.
- β Wanting the title right away, since there's no lien on the car.
- β A small amount you plan to repay quickly.
Even then, compare it with an auto loan quote. The convenience of a personal loan may not be worth a much higher rate.
Dealer financing vs. going direct
If you choose an auto loan, you can get it in two main ways. The CFPB explains that dealer-arranged financing is also called indirect auto financing, because the dealer is between you and the lender. You can also go directly through a bank or credit union to finance your car.
The CFPB says the first step is to get preapproved by a bank or other lender. A preapproval gives you a rate to compare with the dealer's offer, and going direct can help you avoid a dealer markup on the interest rate.
- Check your credit Know where you stand before you shop.
- Get preapproved Ask a bank or credit union for a preapproved auto loan.
- Get a personal loan quote too If you're considering one, compare its APR.
- Let the dealer compete Ask whether the dealer can beat your preapproved rate.
- Compare total cost Look at the APR, term and total of payments.
An example
Two ways to buy the same car
Alex wants to buy a five-year-old sedan from a private seller. He gets two quotes: an auto loan from his credit union and an unsecured personal loan from an online lender.
The auto loan has a lower APR, but the credit union will hold an interest in the title until it's paid off.
The personal loan rate is higher, but Alex would own the car outright. Over three years, the personal loan would cost noticeably more in interest.
Alex chooses the credit union auto loan and uses the savings to build an emergency fund.
Illustrative example. Names are made up. Rates depend on your credit and the lender.
Don't forget the full cost of owning the car
The loan is only one part of the cost. If you finance a car with an auto loan, your lender will usually require collision and comprehensive coverage while you owe money on it, which can raise your insurance cost. With a personal loan, you own the car outright, so the coverage decision is yours, but you'll still need at least your state's required liability coverage.
Add up the loan payment, insurance, fuel, maintenance and registration before you decide what you can afford. A smaller loan on a less expensive car may leave more room in your budget.
- β Get insurance quotes before you buy.
- β Budget for maintenance, especially on older cars.
- β Keep an emergency fund so a repair doesn't become new debt.
If you're behind on a car loan
With a secured auto loan, falling behind can put the car at risk. The CFPB notes that loss of collateral isn't the only consequence of not paying a secured loan; you can also face credit damage, debt collection or being sued. If you're struggling, call your lender before you miss a payment and ask about options.
Questions to ask any lender
Ask each lender for the APR, the loan term, the monthly payment and the total of payments. For an auto loan, ask whether there's a prepayment penalty and what happens to the title when the loan is paid off. For a personal loan, ask about origination fees. Comparing these numbers side by side shows which loan really costs less.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use a personal loan to buy a car from a private seller?
Yes, many people do. Compare its APR with an auto loan quote, since secured loans usually have lower rates.
Is it better to buy a car with an auto loan or a personal loan?
Usually an auto loan, because secured loans usually have lower rates. A personal loan can make sense for older cars or private sales. Compare the APRs.
Is an auto loan secured?
Yes. The CFPB lists car loans as secured loans, where the lender holds an interest in the car until the loan is paid in full.
Are personal loans unsecured?
Most are. The CFPB lists personal loans as an example of unsecured loans.
What happens if I stop paying a personal loan used for a car?
The CFPB says the lender of an unsecured loan can't automatically take your property, but you can face credit damage, collections or a lawsuit.
Should I get preapproved before going to the dealer?
Yes. The CFPB says the first step is to get preapproved by a bank or other lender.
What is indirect auto financing?
Dealer-arranged financing. The CFPB calls it indirect because the dealer is between you and the lender.
Ready to compare loan options?
Compare options available where you live, or call to talk it through with a licensed agent. Looking is free.
ConnectingCrowd is an information site and is not affiliated with any government agency.
Compare personal loan options
SponsoredRelated guides
See all personal loans guides
Secured personal loans: how collateral can lower your rate, and what you put at risk
Unsecured personal loans: borrowing on your credit alone
APR vs interest rate: why the lower rate isn't always the cheaper loan
How loan amortization works: where each payment goes and how to pay less interest
How to check if a lender is licensed in your state, step by step
Earned wage access apps: how paycheck advances work and what they really costSee loan options in your state
Loan options vary by state and lender. Enter your ZIP code to compare options. Looking is free.
Compare loan options for your situation
SponsoredSources
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is based on publicly available sources, which may be incomplete, outdated or incorrect. It is not legal, financial, insurance, tax or medical advice. ConnectingCrowd is not affiliated with any government agency, insurer or lender. Please do your own research and talk to a licensed professional before making any decision.
