Life Insurance Β· Policy decisions

Replacing a life insurance policy? Check these seven things before you switch

A new policy can look cheaper or better on paper. Sometimes it is. But replacing life insurance is not like switching phone plans. You can lose protections you have already earned and take on new costs. Many states require a replacement notice for this reason. Here is what it warns about, in plain English.

Fact-checked against North Carolina Department of Insurance and NAIC. Every source is listed at the end of this article.
Two people reviewing documents at a table
LIFE INSURANCE GUIDE2 yearsHow long claims on most new policies can be denied over inaccurate application answers, per a state replacement notice

Before you replace a policy

  • Do not cancel your current policy until the new one is issued and in force.
  • On most new policies, claims in the first two years can be denied over inaccurate application answers.
  • A suicide limitation may start over on the new policy.
  • If your health has changed, the new policy may cost more, or you may be turned down.
In this article

    The seven checks

    • New two-year claim review window
    • Suicide clause may restart
    • Health changes can raise the price
    • Surrender charges on the old policy
    • New sales costs on the new policy
    • Slower cash value growth on new policies
    • Your old insurer must send policy details if you ask

    From a state replacement notice (North Carolina) and the NAIC life insurance guide.

    Why regulators treat replacement carefully

    Replacing means dropping or reducing an existing policy to buy a new one. Many states, following a model rule from the NAIC, require a written replacement notice when this happens. North Carolina's version is typical. It warns that a replacement may not be in your best interest and lists the specific risks below.

    The NAIC's consumer guide adds a simple rule: do not cancel your current policy until you have the new one.

    The seven things to check

    1. A new review window. The notice says claims on most new policies for up to the first two years can be denied based on inaccurate statements on the application.
    2. The suicide clause. Suicide limitations may begin again on the new coverage.
    3. Your health today. If your health has changed, the new policy could cost more, or you could be turned down. You may also need a medical exam.
    4. Surrender charges. Cashing out the old policy may trigger charges. Ask what they are.
    5. New costs. The sales costs of the old policy may already be paid. A new one comes with new costs.
    6. Slower value growth. New policies usually take longer to build cash value and pay dividends.
    7. Your old insurer's view. You can ask your current company for an in-force illustration or policy summary.

    When replacing can make sense

    SituationWhat to compare
    Your term is ending and you still need coverageThe renewal price on your current policy vs a new term quote
    Your health has improved a lotWhether a new rating lowers the price enough to justify a new two-year window
    You need more coverageAdding a second policy instead of replacing the first
    A permanent policy costs more than you can keep payingOptions from your current insurer before you surrender it

    Ken keeps the old policy for now

    Ken, 52, is offered a new policy that looks cheaper. Since buying his current one, he has been diagnosed with high blood pressure. He applies for the new policy first. It comes back at a higher rating than the quote, so he keeps his current policy and loses nothing because he never canceled it.

    Illustrative example. Pricing depends on the insurer and your health.

    How to replace safely if you go ahead

    1. Get the new policy issued first. Wait until it is approved, delivered and paid.
    2. Answer every application question truthfully. The NAIC warns that false statements could reduce or cancel your coverage.
    3. Keep the sales materials. The replacement notice suggests keeping everything the agent showed you.
    4. Don't rely on illustrations alone. The notice says illustrations should not be the only basis for comparing policies.
    5. Use the free look. The NAIC says you can usually return a new policy for a full refund within about 10 days.
    6. Then cancel the old policy, and update your beneficiary records.

    Questions to ask the agent

    Why is this better for me than keeping what I have? What do I give up? What charges apply to my old policy if I surrender it? What is the highest premium I might ever pay on the new one? The NAIC suggests asking about that last one for any policy.

    Frequently asked questions

    Should I cancel my old life insurance before the new policy starts?

    No. The NAIC says not to cancel your current policy until you get the new one. Wait until the new policy is issued and in force.

    Does a new life insurance policy restart the contestability period?

    Typically, yes. A state replacement notice warns that claims on most new policies can be denied for up to the first two years based on inaccurate application answers.

    Can I get information about my current policy before I decide?

    Yes. A state replacement notice says your current insurer must send an in-force illustration, policy summary or disclosure documents if you ask.

    Your next step

    See life insurance options for your situation

    Compare options available where you live, or call to talk it through with a licensed agent. Looking is free.

    ConnectingCrowd is an information site and is not affiliated with any government agency.

    Compare life insurance options

    Sponsored

    More on life insurance

    Other topics:MedicareAuto insurancePersonal loansHome insuranceDebt reliefAll guides

    See life insurance options in your state

    Policy options and prices vary by state. Enter your ZIP code to see what is available. Looking is free.

    See life insurance options for your situation

    Sponsored
    Was this article helpful?

    Disclaimer: Connecting Crowd is an independent information website. We do not represent any insurance company, lender, agency or government body. Everything on this site is for general information only. Details such as prices, rates and rules can change and may differ slightly from what is shown here, so please do your own research and verify any information with the official source or a qualified professional before making a decision. This page contains advertising, and we may be paid when you click a link or call a number.

    Want to make this easier for your own family?

    Review your own coverage and beneficiaries with a licensed agent so your family knows exactly what to do.