Life Insurance Β· Beneficiaries

Life insurance after divorce: is your ex still the beneficiary, and what should you change?

Divorce papers split the house, the cars and the retirement accounts. The life insurance beneficiary form often gets forgotten, and that one sheet of paper can decide who receives a six-figure check years later. Many states have laws that cancel a former spouse's beneficiary designation when a marriage ends. Those laws don't reach every policy, though, and two U.S. Supreme Court cases show how differently things can turn out. Here's what the Court has said, where the gaps are, and the steps that keep the money going where you intend.

Fact-checked against U.S. Supreme Court opinions and the NAIC. Every source is listed at the end of this article.
Single gold wedding band standing on a dark wooden table
LIFE INSURANCE GUIDECheck itUpdate beneficiaries after a divorce

In 30 seconds

  • In Sveen v. Melin (2018), the U.S. Supreme Court said 26 states had adopted revocation-on-divorce laws similar to the Uniform Probate Code.
  • Under a law like Minnesota's, divorce revokes a revocable beneficiary designation naming a former spouse, and the money goes to the contingent beneficiary or the estate.
  • In Egelhoff v. Egelhoff (2001), the Court held that federal ERISA law preempted Washington's similar statute for an employer plan, so the ex named on the plan form was paid.
  • A divorce court can order that an ex stay on as beneficiary, and a new beneficiary form filed with the insurer can override the state default either way.
In this article

    Life insurance after divorce at a glance

    • State law: many states revoke an ex-spouse's designation at divorce
    • Count cited by the Court in 2018: 26 states with similar laws
    • Employer plans under ERISA: plan documents control (Egelhoff, 2001)
    • Court orders: a divorce decree can require keeping the ex as beneficiary
    • Simplest fix: file a new beneficiary form with each insurer and plan

    From the Supreme Court opinions in Sveen v. Melin (2018) and Egelhoff v. Egelhoff (2001), and the NAIC. This is general information, not legal advice.

    Does divorce remove your ex as beneficiary automatically?

    Sometimes, depending on your state and the type of policy. In Sveen v. Melin, decided in June 2018, the Supreme Court described Minnesota's law, which says the dissolution or annulment of a marriage revokes any revocable beneficiary designation made to a former spouse. If the policyholder dies without changing the form, the proceeds go to the contingent beneficiary or, if there isn't one, to the estate.

    The Court explained that these laws rest on a simple presumption: most divorced people don't want an ex to collect. It also noted that 26 states had adopted revocation-on-divorce laws substantially similar to the Uniform Probate Code. That means a large share of states have such a rule, and many don't. The details can also differ from one state law to the next, so check your own state's rules or ask a family law attorney.

    Revocable is the key word

    The Minnesota law the Court reviewed applies to revocable designations. If you named your spouse as an irrevocable beneficiary, or a court order or settlement covers the policy, different rules can apply. Ask an attorney how your own paperwork reads.

    The Supreme Court case that upheld these laws

    Mark Sveen married Kaye Melin in 1997. In 1998 he bought a life insurance policy naming her as the primary beneficiary and his two children from an earlier marriage as contingent beneficiaries. The couple divorced in 2007. According to the Court, the divorce decree made no mention of the insurance policy, and Sveen never revised his beneficiary designations. He died in 2011.

    Melin and the children both claimed the money. Minnesota had passed its revocation-on-divorce law in 2002, after Sveen bought the policy, so Melin argued that applying it to her violated the Constitution's Contracts Clause. In an 8 to 1 opinion by Justice Kagan, the Court disagreed. It reasoned that the law likely matches what a divorced policyholder would want, that no one can count on a designation surviving divorce because divorce courts can rework it, and that the policyholder can undo the law easily. In the Court's words: "File a form and the statutory default rule gives way to the original beneficiary designation."

    Why work life insurance can play by different rules

    Group life insurance you get through a private employer is often part of a benefit plan governed by the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act, or ERISA. That changes the picture, as Egelhoff v. Egelhoff shows.

    David Egelhoff named his wife, Donna Rae, as beneficiary of a life insurance policy and a pension through his employer, Boeing. Both were ERISA plans. They divorced in April 1994, and a little over two months later he died after an automobile accident, with Donna Rae still listed on both. His children from an earlier marriage argued that Washington's revocation-on-divorce law cut her out.

    The Supreme Court ruled 7 to 2 in 2001 that ERISA preempts the Washington statute as it applies to ERISA plans. The Court said ERISA plans must be run according to their own documents, and that making plan administrators pay whomever state law picks, rather than the beneficiary named in the plan papers, would force them to track the laws of every state. The result: the state's automatic revocation did not apply to those employer plans.

    Type of coverageDoes a state revocation-on-divorce law apply?Case
    Individual policy you bought, in a state with such a lawIt can, as with Minnesota's lawSveen v. Melin (2018)
    Employer plan governed by ERISAThe Court held Washington's law was preempted for ERISA plansEgelhoff v. Egelhoff (2001)
    Any policy covered by a divorce court orderThe order can keep the ex as beneficiaryDescribed in Sveen v. Melin

    Summarized from the two opinions. Rules vary by state and plan. Talk to an attorney about your own situation.

    When a court order says your ex stays on

    Divorce doesn't always mean you're free to drop your ex. The Sveen opinion points out that divorce courts have wide discretion to divide property when a marriage ends, and that a court could direct that an ex-spouse remain as the insurance beneficiary despite the normal revocation rule. A marital settlement agreement can do the same thing.

    Couples sometimes agree to this on purpose. The dissent in Sveen noted that a policyholder might want an ex-spouse to receive insurance money to help care for children of the marriage who live with that ex. If your decree or settlement says you must keep a policy or keep a certain person as beneficiary, changing the form on your own could put you in conflict with the court order. Read your decree closely, and check with your attorney before changing anything.

    How one forgotten form can play out

    Two policies, two different outcomes

    Dana divorced Chris eight years ago and later remarried. She had two life insurance policies: a $250,000 term policy she bought on her own and a group policy through her employer's ERISA benefit plan. Chris was still listed as the beneficiary on both, and her divorce decree didn't mention either one.

    Dana lived in a state with a revocation-on-divorce law much like Minnesota's. For the individual policy, that law could treat Chris's designation as revoked, sending the money to her contingent beneficiary or her estate.

    The group policy is different. Under the reasoning in Egelhoff, the plan administrator pays the person named in the plan documents, and the state law doesn't override that. Chris could collect that benefit even though Dana's new spouse and children were the people she meant to protect.

    Ten minutes with two change-of-beneficiary forms would have avoided both the uncertainty and a possible family dispute.

    Illustrative example. Names are made up. Outcomes depend on state law, plan terms and court orders.

    What to do after a divorce

    1. List every policy and plan Include individual policies, group life through work, and any coverage from a union or association. Don't forget accidental death coverage.
    2. Read your divorce decree and settlement Look for anything that requires you to keep a policy in force or keep your ex, or a trust for your children, as beneficiary.
    3. Ask each insurer or HR for a change-of-beneficiary form The Sveen opinion describes changing a designation as sending a change-of-beneficiary form to your insurer. For work coverage, the plan's own form controls.
    4. Name primary and contingent beneficiaries Use full legal names. The NAIC suggests including the Social Security or tax ID numbers of all beneficiaries and keeping contact details current.
    5. Plan for minor children The NAIC says insurers generally don't pay benefits directly to minors. An estate or trust can manage the money until a child comes of age.
    6. Get written confirmation Keep a copy of the updated form and the insurer's or plan's confirmation with your important papers.

    The NAIC also recommends checking your policies once a year to make sure all beneficiaries are listed. A divorce, a remarriage or a new child is a good reason not to wait for the annual review.

    When to call an attorney

    This article is general information, not legal advice. A family law or estate planning attorney can tell you how your state's law, your plan documents and your divorce papers fit together. That's especially worth doing if:

    • βœ“ Your decree or settlement mentions life insurance, support or a trust for your children.
    • βœ“ You have group coverage through work and aren't sure whether ERISA applies.
    • βœ“ You named your spouse as an irrevocable beneficiary.
    • βœ“ You're the ex-spouse, a child or a new spouse and expect a dispute over a payout.
    • βœ“ You moved to a different state after the divorce or bought the policy before your state's law took effect.

    Frequently asked questions

    Does divorce automatically remove an ex from life insurance?

    In many states, a revocation-on-divorce law treats a revocable designation of a former spouse as revoked. The Supreme Court counted 26 states with laws similar to the Uniform Probate Code in 2018. Other states don't have such a law, and the rules can differ, so check your state.

    Does that state law apply to my life insurance at work?

    Maybe not. In Egelhoff v. Egelhoff (2001), the Supreme Court held that ERISA preempts Washington's revocation-on-divorce law as applied to ERISA employer plans, so the administrator follows the plan documents. Update your work beneficiary form directly.

    What happened in Sveen v. Melin?

    Mark Sveen divorced in 2007 but never changed his beneficiary form, and he died in 2011. The Supreme Court held 8 to 1 that applying Minnesota's revocation-on-divorce law to his earlier policy didn't violate the Contracts Clause.

    Can a divorce court make me keep my ex as beneficiary?

    Yes. The Sveen opinion says divorce courts have wide discretion over property and could direct that an ex remain the insurance beneficiary despite the normal revocation rule. Follow your decree and ask your attorney before changing anything.

    What if I want my ex to stay my beneficiary?

    In a state like Minnesota, the Court said you can file a new form and the default rule gives way. Re-confirming your ex in writing with the insurer after the divorce removes doubt about your wishes.

    Who gets the money if my ex's designation is revoked?

    Under the Minnesota law the Court reviewed, the proceeds go to the contingent beneficiary or, if there is none, to the policyholder's estate.

    Can I name my children instead of my ex?

    Yes, but the NAIC notes insurers generally don't pay benefits directly to minors. An estate or trust can manage the money until the child comes of age. An attorney can help you set that up.

    How often should I check my beneficiaries?

    The NAIC suggests checking your policies once a year and updating them after major life events. A divorce or remarriage is a reason to update right away.

    Your next step

    Planning for your family?

    Compare options available where you live, or call to talk it through with a licensed agent. Looking is free.

    ConnectingCrowd is an information site and is not affiliated with any government agency.

    Compare life insurance options

    Sponsored

    See life insurance options in your state

    Policies vary by state and insurer. Enter your ZIP code to compare options. Looking is free.

    Compare life insurance for your situation

    Sponsored
    Was this article helpful?

    Rebuilding your plans after divorce?

    Compare life insurance options for your new household.